Inherited Jewelry: Should You Sell It, Keep It, or Redesign It?
By Solomon "Sam" Rafidia, owner of European Jewelry

Every week, someone walks into our store with a small box, a tissue-wrapped bracelet, or a handful of old chains from a parent or grandparent. They usually ask the same thing: "What should I do with this?"
I've been helping families answer that question since we opened in 2003. European Jewelry is a family-owned business, and I know these pieces carry more than gold. Here's the honest advice I give every customer.
First, don't rush and don't clean it
If you only take one thing from this post, let it be this: please don't clean or polish a piece you're thinking of selling.
Many people want to make a ring or chain "look nice" before they bring it in. But heavy cleaning and polishing removes a little metal, and the weight of the piece drops in grams. Since gold is bought by weight and purity, that's a small loss you caused yourself. We don't mind dirt or tarnish. Bring it exactly as it is.
Should I sell my inherited jewelry?
If a piece doesn't fit your style, sits in a drawer, or you simply don't need it, selling is a sensible choice. We buy gold, we buy estate jewelry, and we buy old jewelry, including broken chains, single earrings, and damaged rings. Condition matters much less than people think.Here's how it works with us:
We test the metal and purity with professional testing tools.
We price it at the current gold rate.
You get cash on the spot.
Prefer to trade gold for gold? We lock the gold rate on the same day you decide to sell, so a price swing tomorrow won't change your deal.
You can read the full process on our sell your jewelry. If you're looking for a place to sell estate jewelry near Mount Prospect, we're happy to give you a no-obligation appraisal first. You never have to sell on the spot.
When should I keep inherited jewelry?
Keep a piece if it holds a story you want to hand down, even if it isn't worth much. Many families keep one or two meaningful items and sell the rest. That's a good balance, and it's what I recommend when a collection is large.
When is redesign the better answer?
When you love what the piece stands for but not how it looks. This is the part of my work I enjoy most, because I design and handcraft pieces myself, from sketch to finished jewelry.
Here's a story I'm proud of. A young woman came in with her late grandmother's gold bangles. She didn't want to sell them. She wanted to keep her grandmother close. We talked about what she'd actually wear, and together we designed a bracelet made from the same gold, with her grandmother's initial on it.
The bangles were heavy and the bracelet she chose was lighter. So we gave her the remaining value back in cash. She left with a piece she could wear every day, plus money for the difference. Seeing how happy she was is exactly why I do this.
Popular redesigns include:
- Turning old bangles or chains into a new bracelet or necklace
- Reusing a family diamond in a modern setting
- Adding an initial or engraving to make a piece personal
-
Combining several unwanted pieces into one new design
Explore our custom jewelry and redesign services
Serving Mount Prospect and nearby communities
Our store is at 60 E. Northwest Hwy, Mount Prospect, IL 60056. Customers visit us from towns within about 15 miles, including Arlington Heights, Des Plaines, Prospect Heights, Rolling Meadows, Palatine, Elk Grove Village, Wheeling, Park Ridge, Rosemont, Niles, and Schaumburg, as well as the northwest side of Chicago. Visit our
contact page for hours and directions.
About the owner
Solomon "Sam" Rafidia leads European Jewelry, which his family opened in 2003. A proud alumnus of the Gemological Institute of America (GIA), Sam sketches and handcrafts every custom piece and personally sources the diamonds and gemstones the store sells. Learn more about us
Frequently Asked Questions About Custom Jewelry in Chicago
Do you buy old or broken gold jewelry?
Yes. We buy old jewelry in any condition, including broken chains, bent rings, and single earrings.
How do you decide what my gold is worth?
We test the metal and purity, weigh it, and pay based on the current gold rate.
Will I get paid right away?
Yes. We pay cash on the spot.
Can I trade my gold for new jewelry instead of cash?
Yes. We lock in the gold rate the same day you finalize the sale.
Should I clean inherited jewelry before selling it?
No. Cleaning can reduce the weight of the piece, which lowers its value.
Do you charge for appraisals?
No. Appraisals are free and carry no obligation.
Can you turn my grandmother's jewelry into something new?
Yes. Our in-house designer can remake old gold into a bracelet, pendant, or ring, and can add initials or engraving.
Where can I sell estate jewelry near Mount Prospect?
Visit European Jewelry at 60 E. Northwest Hwy, Mount Prospect, IL.